Cassette and CD Reviews


by Michael Morris


Compact Discs of two very different Band Organs are reviewed this time, one of American origin, the other originating in Belgium. They are both of great interest and should appeal to many organ lovers. Fortunately the music can also be obtained on cassette.

It is quite astonishing to see the increasing use of the CD for the reproduction of mechanical music. The Compact Disc combined with a well made digital recording can produce a very clear recording and, if handled carefully, the disc should last almost indefinitely. The programming facilities of most CD players allow for the selection of specific tracks or even random play to add variation to listening. For those who enjoy in-car entertainment, I am sure that cassettes will still be the popular choice for many years to come.

New cassettes or CDs can be sent to me for review at 10 Church Lane, Barnwood, Gloucester GL4 3HZ. Please include historical information and a good photograph if possible.

[Please note that prices shown for carriage are usually inland only and you should check if you are ordering from overseas.]

'Good old USA Carousel Music Vol 2' is a further high class recording of Harvey and Marion Roehl's Wurlitzer Model 146A Band Organ. The cassettes are priced at $10, the CD at $15, and a further $3 should be added to each order to cover postage. Payment in US Dollars should be arranged through your bank and should have the name of a correspondent American bank printed on the face of any cheque, draft or order. The address is Marion Roehl Recordings, 3533 Stratford Drive, Vestal, New York 13850 - 2222 USA.

The splendidly restored Wurlitzer was built at North Tonawanda in the late 1920s and then entertained riders on the carousel in Endicott, New York. Using the Wurlitzer 150 scale, the organ is operated from paper rolls; this scale is very limited and requires a gifted arranger to produce a melodious sound. Fortunately for us, there are a number of very competent musicians who can work wonders with the organ; on this recording we can hear a marvellous selection of pieces arranged by Tom Meijer, a native of the Netherlands who will be known by many members. 20 old-time tunes can be heard, most of them well known. Darktown Strutters' Ball is a very pleasant addition to the organ's repertoire - a piece that I have not heard on a recording before despite the fact that it was composed in 1917 by Shelton Brooks. The entire programme comprises music that was popular before the Second World War and is performed to perfection by the organ that has been restored by Tim Westman of New Hampshire. Likewise the recording by John Mersereau is difficult to fault.

  1. Waitin' for the Robert E Lee
  2. You Made Me Love You
  3. 1 Wonder Who's Kissing Her Now
  4. How You Gonna Keep 'em Down On the Farm After They've Seen Paree?
  5. Put On Your Old Grey Bonnet
  6. American Patrol
  7. 1 Want a Girl Just Like the Girl Who Married Dear Old Dad
  8. I've Got Rings On My Fingers
  9. Come Josephine in My Flying Machine
  10. Over There
  11. Ma, He's Making Eyes at Me
  12. Won't You Come Home, Bill Bailey
  13. Row, Row, Row Your Boat
  14. Ja-Da
  15. Get Out and Get Under
  16. Organ Grinder's Serenade
  17. Rock-A-Bye Your Baby With a Dixie Melody
  18. Goodbye Broadway, Hello France
  19. Darktown Strutters' Ball
  20. High School Cadets

All selections on this album are in the public domain.


'Music from the 68-key DeCap Belgian Band Organ' volume four has just been produced and can be heard on CD and cassette. 'Lucy' was built in Antwerp around 1946 for producing live music for dancing and entertainment, coming to England in 1963, imported by the late Charles Hart. The recordings can be ordered from Keith Pinner by Post - CDs at £8.50 and cassettes at £5. His address is 157 Park Street Lane, St Albans, Herts AL2 2AZ.

Almost every book of music featured was new in 1996 from a variety of noteurs. Keith rebuilt the jazz flute and vibratone tremulants last winter and they now sound much better. He also added a rank of stopped pipes on the accompaniment section to strengthen the hitherto weaker sound of string pipes only. The Compact Disc that I received is of a very high standard, is well balanced, reproducing the sound of the band organ to good effect and is a credit to Keith, the producer and to Location Recording Service. The 22 tracks of varied musical styles makes the recording very entertaining, an ideal addition to members' music collections to while away the long winter evenings.

Specification of 'Lucy' 68-key DeCap Organ:

  1. Dardanella - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  2. La Isla Bonita - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  3. Dixieland Medley - Arthur Prinsen
  4. Whistling Rufus
  5. Dinah
  6. Back Home In Tennessee
  7. Oh You Beautiful Baby
  8. I Want To Be In Dixie
  9. The Sheikh Of Araby
  10. Everybody's Doing It Now
  11. This Ole House - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  12. Lollipop - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  13. Edith Piaf Medley - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  14. Take Me To Your Heart Again
  15. The Three Bells
  16. No Regrets
  17. Padam Padam
  18. If You Love Me
  19. Amsterdam Waltz - Arie Bekker
  20. Kaspian Sea - A DeCap
  21. AI Jolson Medley - Keith Pinner
  22. Waiting For The Robert E Lee
  23. Carolina In The Morning
  24. Pretty Baby
  25. Toot Toot Tootsie (Goo'bye)
  26. I'm Sitting On Top Of The World
  27. I'm Looking Over A Four Leaf Clover
  28. Chinatown, My Chinatown
  29. Baby Face
  30. The Streets Of London - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  31. Give Me The Organ - A DeCap
  32. Fifty Years Of Song - Arthur Prinsen
  33. The Soldiers Of The Queen
  34. Where Did You Get That Hat
  35. Ta Ra Ra Boom De Ay
  36. The Man That Broke The Bank At Monte Carlo
  37. Lily Of Laguna
  38. Tell Me Pretty Maiden
  39. Just Like The Ivy
  40. I Love A Lassie
  41. Let's All Go Down The Strand
  42. Waiting For The Robert E Lee
  43. You Made Me Love You
  44. A Broken Doll
  45. Swanee
  46. Love Is The Sweetest Thing
  47. It Ain't Gonna Rain No More
  48. Accordion Parade - Arie Bekker
  49. Lambada - Arie Bekker
  50. Wedding Samba - Jan Kees de Ruijter
  51. Savoy American Medley - Arthur Prinsen
  52. Who Are You Kiddin': Mr Hitler - Ken Slow
  53. Circus Renz - Arie Bekker
  54. La Mer - Arthur Prinsen
  55. Let's Twist Again - Andrew Pilmer
  56. My Prayer - Keith Pinner
  57. Love and Marriage - Jan Kees de Ruijter

Review © 1996 Michael Morris

Originally published in edition 4 of The Key Frame 1996.


Articles Index

Homepage